Gianni De Gennaro’s death: what happens now to Italy’s Via D’Amelio cover-up probe? A criminal lawyer explains

Gianni De Gennaro’s death: what happens now to Italy’s Via D’Amelio cover-up probe? A criminal lawyer explains

By Danilo Iacobacci, criminal defense lawyer admitted to Italy’s Court of Cassation, Ph.D. in European Union Criminal Policy

Gianni De Gennaro, Italy’s former national police chief and former head of its intelligence services, died on Saturday 21 November 2026 at his country house in Montiano, in the province of Grosseto, Tuscany. He was 78. According to initial reports, he took his own life. Only days earlier, prosecutors in Caltanissetta, Sicily, had placed him under investigation for obstructing justice in the inquiry into the Via D’Amelio bombing. On 19 July 1992, that Mafia attack in Palermo killed anti-Mafia judge Paolo Borsellino and five officers of his police escort.

Beyond the grief and the controversy, the case raises precise legal questions. What happens to an investigation when the suspect dies? What does the newly opened “incitement to suicide” file mean? And what does this tell us about the weight of criminal proceedings long before any verdict? Here is my answer as an Italian criminal defence lawyer.

The Caltanissetta investigation

According to press reports, the Caltanissetta prosecutors are investigating the chain of command under Arnaldo La Barbera, the former head of Palermo’s flying squad, who died in 2002. The focus is on how the first investigation into the bombing was steered off course. In 1992 De Gennaro was deputy director of the DIA, Italy’s anti-Mafia investigative directorate. The alleged offence is depistaggio, a specific crime of misleading or obstructing an investigation, introduced into Article 375 of the Italian Criminal Code in 2016.

There were two allegations:

  • misleading through testimony: persuading the Mafia informant Salvatore Contorno not to give statements to the Caltanissetta prosecutors;
  • misleading through evidence: hiding and destroying paper and digital documents, allegedly moved after 2023 searches of La Barbera’s relatives, in connection with the hunt for Borsellino’s missing “red diary”.

De Gennaro’s property was searched on 12 November 2026. Prosecutors asked for him to be placed under house arrest. The judge for preliminary investigations, Giulia Zappalà, refused: she found no serious evidence that he had intended to obstruct the inquiry into the bombing. In her view, the material might concern other matters, such as Contorno’s 1989 arrest, the anonymous “Raven” letters in Palermo, and the failed 1989 attempt on Judge Giovanni Falcone’s life at Addaura. The prosecutors appealed to the review tribunal, which was due to rule on 1 December.

What happens to the case now

With De Gennaro’s death, the case against him ends without any ruling on the merits. Under Article 150 of the Italian Criminal Code, the death of the accused before a final conviction extinguishes the offence. Because the case was still at the preliminary investigation stage, the prosecutor will have to request that it be dismissed on that ground (Article 411 of the Code of Criminal Procedure).

This has three practical consequences:

  1. The appeal on house arrest falls away. The review hearing set for 1 December no longer has anything to decide. No court will rule on whether there was serious evidence against him or a need for precautionary measures.
  2. There will never be a verdict on him. There will be no conviction, but no acquittal stating that the facts did not occur either. Under Article 27 of the Italian Constitution, De Gennaro dies an innocent man, and Italian law does not allow a trial of a deceased person. His family therefore cannot seek a judgment to clear his name.
  3. The investigation continues for others. According to the press, some of his former colleagues are also under investigation; their names have not been made public. Their cases go on, and the documents and evidence gathered remain in the file and can still be used.

There is also a question that goes beyond the law. Thirty-four years after the bombing, the search for the truth about Via D’Amelio has lost a voice that can no longer be heard, either as a suspect or as a witness.

The incitement-to-suicide file

Prosecutors in Grosseto, together with the anti-Mafia directorate (DDA) in Florence, have opened a file for incitement to suicide. The label sounds dramatic, but in cases like this it is usually a routine procedural step, not an accusation against anyone.

Article 580 of the Italian Criminal Code punishes anyone who leads another person to take their own life, strengthens their intention to do so, or helps them carry it out. When there is a violent death, opening a file under this heading allows investigators to order a post-mortem, carry out forensic tests and interview witnesses. According to the press, investigators are hearing people close to De Gennaro and looking for camera footage to retrace his movements and rule out the presence of anyone else.

Some reactions have gone further. Salvatore Borsellino, the judge’s brother, accused the Caltanissetta prosecutors of incitement to suicide. De Gennaro’s lawyer, Francesco Bertorotta, said the act may have been the result of “defamatory accusations”. These words are understandable on a human level, but they must be kept separate from the legal assessment. Conducting an investigation in accordance with the law, ordering a search or requesting a precautionary measure is the performance of a legal duty (Article 51 of the Criminal Code). In itself, it does not amount to the offence under Article 580. Whether the justice system is able to measure the impact its actions have on people is a different question, and the subject of the next section.

Presumption of innocence and the weight of proceedings

De Gennaro had not been charged, let alone convicted. He was only under investigation, and a judge had just found that there was no serious evidence against him. Yet in the public mind his name was already linked to the cover-up of the Via D’Amelio bombing, one of the most painful chapters in Italy’s history. It was not the first time: years earlier he had been prosecuted in proceedings arising from the 2001 G8 summit in Genoa, and was finally acquitted by Italy’s Supreme Court of Cassation.

The presumption of innocence (Article 27 of the Italian Constitution, EU Directive 2016/343, implemented in Italy by Legislative Decree 188/2021) is not only a rule of evidence. It also forbids presenting as guilty anyone who has not been tried. In practice, in Italy, being placed on the register of suspects is often read as a conviction in advance, and the time between the first notice of investigation and a verdict can run to years.

Those of us who do this job see it every day: criminal proceedings are already a punishment, even before any sentence. We do not know, and may never know, how much this weighed on De Gennaro’s decision, and it is not for a lawyer to speculate. But his death should remind everyone, judges, prosecutors, lawyers and journalists alike, that behind every case file there is a human being.

Conclusion

The case against Gianni De Gennaro ends without a judicial truth: neither guilty nor innocent, only an extinguished offence. The search for the truth about Via D’Amelio goes on by other routes and against other suspects. What remains is a question for everyone who works in the justice system: how to establish the facts, even the gravest ones, without forgetting that the presumption of innocence applies until the final verdict.

Sources

Chiamaci!